Thinking about skipping the hours of prep, cooking, and cleaning this Thanksgiving?
Sarasota has you covered. Whether you’re craving a traditional turkey dinner, an upscale holiday experience, or a gourmet take-home feast, these local restaurants are serving special menus for both dine-in and takeout. Make your reservation early — these spots fill fast!
🍽️ Thanksgiving Dinner Specials in Sarasota
Bevardi’s Salute! Restaurant
If you want a traditional Thanksgiving feast with an Italian twist, Bevardi’s Salute! in downtown Sarasota delivers the perfect blend of comfort and elegance. Their three-course menu includes house-made butternut squash bisque, slow-roasted turkey with chef-made stuffing, honey-glazed sweet potatoes, Chianti cranberry sauce, and warm apple pie à la mode.
Hours: 1–8 p.m.
Price: $49.95 adults, $29.95 children under 12
Reservations: 941-365-1012
Café Gabbiano
Located in Siesta Key Village, Café Gabbiano is a cozy and intimate option for those craving Italian flavors. Enjoy a traditional turkey dinner with garlic mashed potatoes and cranberry sauce, or elevate your meal with aged filet mignon, braised veal, or honey-truffle salmon. Their extensive wine list seals the deal.
Hours: 2–8 p.m.
Reservations: 941-349-1423
Columbia Restaurant
A Sarasota classic on St. Armands Circle, Columbia offers its famous Spanish-Cuban dishes alongside Thanksgiving specials. Expect sliced roast turkey, sausage-apple stuffing, sweet potato pecan casserole, rich gravy, and their signature pumpkin flan.
Reservations: 941-388-3987
Drift Kitchen & Bar (Lido Beach Resort)
With panoramic Gulf views from the rooftop, Drift Kitchen offers a stunning holiday setting. Dine on a Thanksgiving buffet with classics, or opt for standout entrées like harissa-roasted chicken or pork chops with pineapple agrodolce.
Reservations: 941-388-2161
Duval’s Fresh. Local. Seafood.
Duval’s offers both dine-in and a family-style feast for pickup or free delivery. Their Thanksgiving spread includes herb-roasted turkey, honey-mustard ham, sweet potato mash, rustic mashed potatoes, salad, rolls, cranberry sauce, and your choice of pumpkin or key lime pie.
Dine-In: $54 adults, $30 children under 10
Takeout: Serves 4–6; $189 by Oct. 31 or $209 after
Reservations: 941-312-4001
Element: Steak • Seafood • Pasta
Located in downtown Sarasota, Element offers a refined holiday experience. Past menus have featured turkey legs with orange-cranberry-ginger glaze, classic sides, and uniquely elevated entrées like scallops and salmon.
Reservations: 941-724-8585
EVOQ (The Westin Sarasota)
EVOQ’s Thanksgiving buffet highlights citrus-brined turkey, rosemary prime rib, smoked gouda mac & cheese, roasted Brussels sprouts with butternut squash, and desserts like pumpkin torte and Dutch apple pie.
Hours: Noon–5 p.m.
Price (incl. tax & gratuity): $93 adults, $59 children 12 and under
Bonus: Free valet for buffet guests
Libby’s Neighborhood Brasserie
With locations in Southside Village and Lakewood Ranch, Libby’s serves a classic Thanksgiving plate featuring roasted turkey breast, mushroom cream gravy, sweet potato mash, sage-brioche stuffing, and hot-honey carrots. Available for dine-in or takeout.
Reservations: 941-487-7300
Mattison’s Restaurants
Mattison’s makes Thanksgiving easy with a full Complete Feast To Go that serves up to 8 people. Enjoy a whole roasted turkey, apple-walnut stuffing, mashed sweet potatoes, roasted vegetables, and rolls with Boursin butter. Available at all three locations.
Price: $295
Orders: 941-921-3400
Prefer dining out? All locations are open for à la carte Thanksgiving dining.
Michael’s On East
For an upscale Thanksgiving celebration, Michael’s on East offers a Four-Diamond dining experience. Their holiday menu includes traditional turkey dinners and elevated dishes from a limited à la carte menu — plus live music and outdoor seating.
Reservations: 941-366-0007 (waitlist likely)
Takeout: Family-style or individual meals; orders due by Nov. 22
Ophelia’s on the Bay
One of Sarasota’s most elegant waterfront restaurants, Ophelia’s pairs a peaceful Siesta Key setting with a holiday menu featuring classic turkey dinners and seasonal entrées like Alaskan halibut with dashi beurre blanc.
Hours: 4–9 p.m.
Reservations: 941-349-2212
Pop’s Sunset Grill
For a creative, chef-driven takeout feast, Pop’s offers scratch-made Thanksgiving catering featuring roast turkey, apple cider–glazed pork loin, acorn squash, traditional stuffing, cauliflower pilaf, and festive desserts.
Orders: 941-363-1709
🥧 Year-Round Comfort Classics
Der Dutchman (Pinecraft)
Der Dutchman is famous for its Amish cooking, buffets, and incredible pies. Enjoy dine-in Thanksgiving with turkey, mashed potatoes, vegetables, and all the classics — or order a family feast for up to 20.
Bakery Favorites: Pecan, pumpkin, Dutch apple
Reservations/Orders: 941-955-8007
Yoder’s Restaurant & Amish Village
While Yoder’s is closed on Thanksgiving Day, you can preorder their beloved pies — with over 30 flavors available. Pumpkin cream, Southern pecan, and cherry are always hits.
Orders: 941-955-7771
Final Tips
✔ Reservations are essential — many restaurants fill weeks in advance.
✔ Preorder takeout early, especially full-family feasts and pies.
✔ Check pickup windows and deadlines.
✔ Consider supporting multiple local spots — dine in at one, pick up dessert from another!
